Book Review of Gimme Some Sugar

Gimme Some Sugar

A Southern Eclectic Novel

Molly Harper

Gallery Books

April 2, 2019

Blurb: Lucy Brewer would never have guessed that her best friend, Duffy McCready (of McCready’s Bait Shop & Funeral Home) has been in love with her since they were kids. Fear of rejection and his own romantic complications prevented Duffy from confessing his true feelings in high school, so he stood by and watched her wed Wayne Bowman right after high school. Wayne had always been a cheapskate, so it comes as no surprise when he suffers a fatal accident while fixing his own truck.

Even as her family and friends invade Lucy’s life and insist that the new widow is too fragile to do much beyond weeping, Lucy is ashamed to admit that life without Wayne is easier, less complicated. After all, no one knew what a relentless, soul-grinding trudge marriage to Wayne had been. Only Duffy can tell she’s hiding something.

In need of a fresh start, Lucy asks Duffy to put his cabinet-building skills to use, transforming the town’s meat shop into a bake shop. As the bakery takes shape, Lucy and Duffy discover the spark that pulled them together so many years ago. Could this finally be the second chance he’s always hoped for?

Once again Molly Harper “writes characters you can’t help but fall in love with” (RT Book Reviews) in this charming and entertaining love story.


I finished Molly Harper’s latest installment in The Southern Eclectic series,
Gimme Some Sugar, yesterday and have been trying to figure out this review ever since. You see, I have loved, adored, been over-the-top about each of the novels in this series until this one. Was it a bad book? By no means. To me, it just felt like it was missing something. 

Duffy has been one of my favorite characters from the beginning, although his questionable, albeit slightly understandable, interactions with his ex-wife, Lana, raised eyebrows. But Duffy is such a nice guy that I don’t think he could bear anyone feeling bad, even if that anyone is a selfish, despicable creature like Lana. So I was very happy to read Duffy’s book and had actually been looking forward to it.

Also, Lucy is a nice addition to the cast of characters, but I didn’t come away loving her the way I had Frankie, Margot, or Marianne. I felt sometimes she didn’t take responsibility for her own actions and her stands balanced out her wishy-washiness so that she seemed blander to me. But, again, after creating characters like Margot and Frankie, sometimes you have to have one that is blander because they all can’t be the same.

It’s occurred to me that I started reading Gimme Some Sugar right after a book (review coming up in a few days) that had me rolling on the floor laughing and that might have affected my reading. Some of the jokes here felt a little recycled from previous novels in the series in comparison.


Gimme Some Sugar is still one of the best books I’ve read this year. It’s fun to visit these characters who I’ve grown to have so much affection for. Every book in this series is like a cure for a bad day.

Who will like Gimme Some Sugar? Molly Harper fans, readers of The Southern Eclectic series, readers who enjoy southern fiction with a sense of humor, readers who find the idea of an all-in-one baitshop and mortuary fun, readers who like all of their food deep-fried.

I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Buy Links:

Amazon | Barnes and NobleIndieBound

rating: 4-butterflies

4 out of 5 butterflies



6 thoughts on “Book Review of Gimme Some Sugar

    1. It’s hard to put things in perspective when you’re disappointed and hard to decide why exactly you’re disappointed and yet still try to get across that this is so much better than so many books out there. (Hopefully I did that.) 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.